Kylian Mbappé’s knee injury has sparked questions after reports of a wrong-leg MRI. Here’s ProFootballDoc - Dr David Chao's analysis on how the diagnostic error may have happened and why it matters.

Kylian Mbappé’s knee issue became a much bigger story once questions emerged over whether the wrong knee was initially scanned, turning a routine injury evaluation into a broader discussion about medical process and accountability. On the Sports Injury Central podcast, Pro Football Doc said the case likely reflects a breakdown in communication and follow-through more than a single isolated mistake.

Mbappé’s discomfort reportedly dated back to December, with discussion around a possible PCL-related issue. The bigger concern, however, was the possibility that the first MRI was performed on the wrong side, potentially delaying a correct diagnosis and proper treatment plan.

Pro Football Doc outlined several ways that kind of error can happen. A physician could write the wrong side on the order. A prior knee issue in the medical chart could create confusion. A nurse or tech could misunderstand verbal instructions. Or, in the case of a superstar athlete, staff may move too quickly and set up imaging without the same step-by-step office evaluation a typical patient would receive.

That is where the star factor can become part of the problem. Pro Football Doc suggested that in elite sports medicine, people can get sped up by the athlete’s profile and let the sports side interfere with the medical side. Instead of slowing down and confirming the exact complaint, the exact knee and the exact sequence of evaluation, the process can become rushed.

He also noted that the player himself may not always catch the error during the MRI. With the body positioned inside the machine, the athlete may not clearly know which knee is being imaged. The MRI tech is supposed to confirm the correct side, and the coil should be placed on the knee being studied, but that safeguard only works if the communication is clear and the process is followed carefully.

Even if the wrong knee is scanned, the mistake still should be caught afterward. Pro Football Doc noted that the MRI report marks the side, and a physician reviewing the images should also be able to tell whether it is the right or left knee. That means the breakdown may have extended beyond the order itself and into the review process.

His explanation was that there may have been a disconnect between the imaging and the actual clinical exam. Rather than bringing Mbappé in, examining the knee and matching the MRI to the complaint, someone may have simply reviewed the images remotely, saw no major issue and reported that the scan looked clean. According to Pro Football Doc, that kind of disassociation is how the wrong-side problem can persist until a second opinion forces a more careful evaluation.

For a player like Mbappé, that matters because knee injuries are rarely minor in practical terms, even when they are not catastrophic. Any PCL-related or similar ligament issue can affect explosiveness, deceleration, cutting and balance, all of which are central to his game. A delayed or incorrect read can extend symptoms and complicate return-to-play planning.

The biggest takeaway from Pro Football Doc’s analysis is simple: elite athletes still need basic medical discipline. The order has to match the complaint. The scan has to match the injured side. The doctor has to match the images to the patient in front of him. When that chain breaks, even a world-class player can wind up with the wrong answer.


Sign up to our FREE Weekly Newsletter here for all of our best injury-insights, free injury-based picks and special discount offers!

Need help with your Sports Picks?

🔥Our Injury Edge is cashing in with our best NBA and NCAAM seasons ever, +18 units in NCAAM and the proven NBA health model is 57% ATS! Claim 20% off SIC Picks Passes for Picks with our Injury Edge, offer ends 3/29 - Use code: MADNESS

Now is the time to get the best value with SIC Picks! Sign up this week using the promo code MADNESS for 20% off a Weekly or Annual subscription and get:

  • NCAAB picks are +9 units this March Madness and +18 units overall this season.

  • Our NFL and NBA model have won at over 56.5% ATS since we started seven years ago on NFL and over four years on NBA!

  • NFL +30 units on Spread Picks in 2025 and over 56.5%

  • Just $1.10 per day on the annual plan

Sign up to SIC Picks today to get our picks sent direct to your cell! 

SIC PICKS ARE INSIDER INJURY KNOWLEDGE FROM FORMER PRO SPORTS TEAM DOCTORS TO GIVE YOU A WINNING EDGE IN SPORTS BETTING!

SIC PICKS are powered by the proven SIC Score algorithms from our exclusive panel of former Pro Sports Team doctors to give you a sports betting edge. Each day our team of doctors analyze the players and teams and share their expert insights to help you make informed bets on the biggest unknown to sportsbooks and sports bettors - player health and injuries!  

For our Best Bets including spreads, totals, props and live in game with instant alerts as game day opportunities arise with research notes, sign up to SIC Picks here for less than $2 a day on an annual plan.

Sign up to SIC Picks today to get our picks sent direct to your cell!