Is the NFL Concussion Return to Play Protocol More Strict This Season?

2 min read • October 03, 2023

Posted in

NFL
Is the NFL Concussion Return to Play Protocol More Strict This Season?

Through Week 4, just over 13% of players have cleared concussion protocol to return without missing a game, according to analysis from the SIC score staff.

Green Bay Packers linebacker Quay Walker returned in Week 2 despite a Week 1 concussion and Houston Texans safety Eric Murray made it back for Week 3 despite suffering a concussion the week prior.

Through Week 4, 12 of 15 players have missed one game after suffering a concussion and just one of 15 have missed two games (Colts Center Ryan Kelly).

After the concussion controversy regarding Tua Tagovailoa last season, this number represents a dip in the percentage of players clearing concussion protocol to play the next week.

Last year, roughly 22% of players were able to clear concussion protocol and return without missing a game.

Unfortunately, the shift has already affected key players with Anthony Richardson, Jaylen Waddle, Jimmy Garoppolo and Jakobi Meyers all missing the following week after suffering a concussion.

Our staff will continue to track this issue, but any player who gets a concussion is more than likely to miss the following week.

Our analysis was based on in-game reports of concussion evaluations, video analysis and on practice reports. 

Any player who cleared concussion protocol to return in the same game was not counted as a concussion (Justin Fields, Tyler Lockett). Any player who left for a concussion evaluation shortly before the game ended, but was able to clear concussion protocol on Wednesday was also not included (Davante Adams, Gus Edwards).

Get Access to All Field Views and SIC Health Scores with SIC Data